For an IT services company with about fifty employees, the first question is who will sign the work. A company's statutory audit and tax audit must be signed by a practising chartered accountant. Ask each firm directly whether its partner holds a current practising membership, and ask for the membership number so you can check it on ICAI's website.
Compare the scope rather than the price. Ask what returns and filings the firm handles for a company your size, who will be your day-to-day contact, and how they plan to keep your books current month to month. Several listings here describe auditing or tax preparation, so ask whether one firm can cover both your accounts and your returns.
Confirm the arrangement in writing before any work starts. Ask for the scope, the fee structure, the expected deliverables and how documents will be shared. Visit or call during opening hours, since some listings here close on Sundays and others have no hours at all.