Start by deciding what you need. Some listings here do internet marketing, others build software or run training. For a chartered accountant, lawyer or consultant, a website and local search visibility are often the first priority, while a software firm suits a larger system or reporting need.
Ask each agency for a short list of past clients in your field and what they changed for them. Ask who will handle your account day to day, what reporting you will receive and how often. Compare the monthly fees and project fees in writing, and check whether any paid ads are billed separately.
Use the hours on each card to plan a call, and note which offices have wheelchair access if a client needs it. Ask for a written scope before you agree to anything, so you know what is included.