Start by asking whether the firm has dealt with notices on the income tax e-filing portal and what it needs from you first. A notice usually asks for books, bank statements, invoices and return copies. A firm that asks for these early is planning the reply properly. Ask who will sign the reply and whether a chartered accountant in practice will handle the audit part.
Check the firm's credentials before you hand over documents. A company's statutory audit, a tax audit and any certificate carrying a UDIN must be signed by a chartered accountant in practice. You can look up a CA's membership number or a firm's registration number on ICAI's website and check a UDIN on ICAI's UDIN portal. Some businesses on this page are listed as tax consultants rather than chartered accountants, so confirm that point directly.
Compare firms on what they list and how they will work with you, not on who is biggest. Note which ones state tax planning, tax representation or audit services in their own words, and ask how they plan to stay within the law for your year. Since the Income-tax Act, 2025 applies from 1 April 2026 while earlier years follow the 1961 Act, confirm with the firm which law and form names apply to your notice.