Start by asking each firm whether it handles company incorporation, the paperwork to register a private limited company, and the filings that follow. Some listings here say chartered accountant, others say tax consultant or auditor. Ask what each one is qualified to sign, because certain work, such as a statutory audit, must be signed by a practising chartered accountant. You can check a CA's membership number or a firm's registration number on ICAI's website.
Compare the fee structure in writing before you sign anything. Ask what is included in the first year, whether bookkeeping and GST work are extra, and who will be your day-to-day contact. Note the opening hours of each firm, since some are closed on Sundays and others have shorter Saturday hours. Ask how they prefer to receive your documents and how quickly they reply to calls and messages.