Start by asking whether the firm does individual income tax returns, not only company audits. Listings here show a mix of audit, accounting and tax consulting, so the wording of the category matters. Ask who will prepare your return and whether a chartered accountant will sign it.
Bring your pension statement, bank interest certificates and last year's return. Ask how they will treat pension and interest income, which forms apply to your year, and whether TDS on your interest has been correctly credited. Ask for their fee in writing before you start, and confirm the process for filing.
Compare firms by how clearly they answer these questions, their hours and how easily you can reach them. Several firms here are in neighbouring localities, so factor in travel time. Check any CA's membership number on ICAI's website before you hand over documents.