Start by sorting the list by what you need. A buyer or seller needs an agency that handles residential sales, while a business looking for space needs a commercial real estate agency. Check the services line on each card before you call anyone.
Next, compare the hours with your own schedule. Some offices close on Sundays, which can matter if you plan to visit a property at the weekend. Others are open every day, and a few run around the clock, so you can reach them at any hour.
Last, ask each agent about the extras you may need, such as financial and legal help, rent collection or lease management. Keep a short list of two or three agents and compare their answers before you decide.