Start by deciding what you need. A hotel, PG or serviced apartment usually needs a website that takes bookings, local search visibility and photos or video of the property. Some businesses on this list are software companies that build systems, and others are design studios. Matching the work to the need saves time.
Ask each agency for examples of work similar to yours, and ask who will handle your account day to day. Check whether the agency works in branding, web, print or ads, as several listings here cover more than one. Ask about timelines and what happens after launch.
Compare two or three businesses on the same questions: services, hours, whether they are in Shettihalli or a neighbouring area, and whether they answer calls. Ask for written quotes. Where a listing shows no price, NammaBiz's price list for its own agency is on its card.