Start by asking whether the firm handles income tax notices and assessments, not just filing returns. Some listings here show income tax filings, tax planning or audit and assurance, while others show only a chartered accountant or a tax consultant. Ask what they have done for proprietors with notices like yours, and who on the team would deal with it.
Check the listing details carefully. Some Ulsoor entries give full addresses and hours, while a few give only a locality. Confirm the office, the working days and the name of the person you will deal with. Where a listing shows a website, look at it to see the services, but treat the claims as the firm's own.
Ask what they will need from you before the reply goes in: the notice itself, your books, bank statements and invoices for the years named. A firm that asks for these clearly is one you can work with. Ask for their fee in writing before you hire them, and whether any work is reserved for a chartered accountant in practice.