Start by matching the service to the goal. A listing that names paid ads, SEO and social media is aimed at sales and reach. A listing that names software development, APIs or cloud is aimed at building and running technology. Many cards here are software companies, so check the services line before calling.
Ask each agency for work similar to yours, such as an online store or a consumer brand, and how results are reported. Compare the years on each card, since older listings like Cobian Software Solutions (2014) show a longer track record than newer ones. Ask who will actually run your account.
Compare the pricing and terms in writing. Ask every business for a written quote covering scope, timelines and what happens if you cancel.