For an IT services company with about fifty employees, start by asking who would do your statutory audit and tax audit. Work the law reserves for a practising chartered accountant must be signed by one. Ask for the membership number and check it on ICAI's website before you hire.
Ask each firm about its experience with companies of your size and with the returns your year requires. The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026, while returns for earlier years still follow the old law. Confirm with the CA which forms and numbers apply to you.
Compare the firms on what their listings show: the services they are listed for, their hours, and whether they have a website to check. Put the same questions to each one, and get the fee and the timeline in writing before you agree.